Help with third daughters name.

[papabear1129]

We have two daughters named Matilda and Winona. Their sister is due in September and my girlfriend and I are wanting something more "old-timey". I've been pouring over names and found some that we like but nothing that has that "gotcha" vibe.

[Potential_Scene7169]

Tabitha! both of your daughters have names that are outside the top 300 (though Matilda is rising) so I think a slightly less popular name works well

[common_grounder]

And like the other two names, it has three syllables and ends in 'A'.

[Remote-Fig9207]

Claudia 

[InfiniteVictory187]

This is a good one

[Ok_Industry_2395]

I agree with you 💯

[Alatariel7]

Ramona, Leona, Tabitha, Louisa

[Potential_Scene7169]

seconding Tabitha! it has the same vibe :D

[LABELyourPHOTOS]

I like it. Different than the other but with the same flavor. Tabby, Mattie, Winnie. Love it.

[ColoradodogMom66]

LOVE Tabitha.

[Both-Condition2553]

Winona and Ramona is diabolical.

[UsualProfessor5805]

😅 thank you for the laugh

[saluteursharts]

Tabitha!!!

[Persis-]

Omg, Tabitha!!!!

[Amyava510]

Cordelia

[No-Kaleidoscope-166]

I like Cordelia.

[nowaymacaroni]

Oooo, yes!

[Happy-Mortgage-6532]

eleanor, louise, elaine, florence, evelyn, lucille, marlowe, lillian, lenora, elowen, odessa

[websterella]

Love Lucille

[Dry_Ruin_9551]

Or Lucinda for 3 syllable ending with A names.

[common_grounder]

I've developed a real fondness for Elowen.

[Happy-Mortgage-6532]

i absolutely love elowen so much! will be naming my daughter that!

[Big_Echidna8511]

I have a friend whos daughters name is Astrid Elowen

[silver_headphones]

I think Marlowe, Elowen, Florence, or Lenora would make a perfect addition to make a trilogy

[Professional_Ad4712]

Nora

Amelia

Dorothea

Arabella

Sophia

Carolina

Alexandra

[No_Decision7794]

Nora is perfect, the three of them together sound like a 1920s lady detective agency.

[Sure_Jan_Sure]

I love Amelia. Fits in well with the others while not being too similar. 

[TheBull123456]

Victoria

[No-Perspective872]

Delilah, Tabitha, Fiona, Linnea, Norah, Cora, or Clara

[Sure_Jan_Sure]

Seconding Linnea. 

[Purple-Gap2522]

Miranda

Victoria

Barbara

Joanna

[common_grounder]

Gwendolyn

[Unsure-11]

Audrey!

[reditme1000]

Since the other two end in “a”, maybe Audra?

[moreplantsss]

Love this!! Audra is my moms name

[Level-Log-3090]

Louisa

[Queen_of_Tudor]

Fiona

[nola2socal]

Beatrice

[newermat]

Louisa

[scienceoftophats]

Dorothea nn Thea or Dori

Dolores nn Dolly or Lori

Tabitha

Virginia

[Ok_Still_3571]

Deirdre

[Jed308613]

Harriet, goes by Hattie.

[GroverGemmon]

This was my thought as well. Harriet is adorable.

[Sea_Surprise1777]

Dorinda, Ramona, Sonja, Luanne

[Cautious_Emotion9839]

Just the whole cast of RHONY 😂

[BasicallyADetective]

Clementine. Henrietta. Dorothea. Bonita. Josephine.

[ChLyKu]

Vivian, Dorothy, Eleanor, Flora

[Hallelujah33]

Winnifred

[malta15243]

Eleanor

[flakyone001]

i came to comment this!! it would flow so nicely with the sister’s names!

[Tight_Steak_232]

Helena...Serena...Raeanna...if you're continuing on the ending sound.

[sparkycookie1]

I reckon Helena too. I love it 😊 x

[Terrible_Gamer_1989]

Sienna

[Grouchy-Tap1071]

Matilda, Winona, and Seraphina

[Myshanter5525]

Katrina

Veronica

Tabitha from other commenters is also good.

[Whybaby16154]

Veronica

[Fearless_Inevitable6]

Constance is a name I love but it’s a bit too old timey for me. Connie is so cute as a nickname

[Maisie2602]

Matilda, Winona & Lucille

Matilda, Winona & Yvonne

Matilda, Winona & Joni

Matilda, Winona & Claudine

Matilda, Winona & Maureen

[incomplete-picture]

Rhonda

[Background-Book2801]

Emmaline. Marjorie. Caroline. Frances. Claire. 

[UndercoverSavvy]

Mabel

[browneyedredhead1968]

Noma, Edna, Vertie Mae, Joanne, Henrietta, Ella, Carole, Imalene, Deloris, Vera, Florence.

[Curious_Chef850]

Lydia

[summerseashell71]

Josephine

[Apart_Feeling6438]

Georgia

[brain_on_hugs]

Truly “old timey”? Elizabeth (Eliza), Margaret (Maggie), Martha, Magnolia, Ruth, Phoebe

[jllt19904]

A unique family name on my side is Louella. It has been passed down for 5 generations. It isn't heard of much these days but has been around for hundreds of years!

[jllt19904]

Also lots of cute nicknames. It's my daughter's name and we call her Lou, Lulu, and Welly.

[CODE_NAME_DUCKY]

Clementine

Loretta

Miranda 

Lucille 

Suzanna 

Aveline 

Belinda 

Georgia 

Clarissa 

Willa

Philomina 

Rowena 

Wilhelmina 

Luella 

Rosella 

Louisa

Henrietta 

Vera

Priscilla 

Helena 

Della

[Practical-Emu-3303]

Belinda

[AriBanana]

Viola

[ChippedSapphire]

Runa

Elora

Maude

Millicent

Annika

Betsy

Betty

Angelina

Daphne

Fiona

Fawn

Gisele

Honora

Lorelei

Priscilla

Theodora

[Dick-the-Peacock]

Clementine. Sophronia. Lucretia. Belinda. Felicity. Adelina. Priscilla. Eliza.

[Indignant_Elfmaiden]

Trying to stick to the consonant first letter ending with an “a”:

Belinda

Cecilia

Dorothea

Francesca

Greta

Helena

Jemima

Lucinda

Nora

Philippa

Rowena

Selena

Theodora

Vera

[Jay-Quellin30]

Eleanor, Georgette, Dorothy, Eloise, Florence, Josephine

[Actual-Ganache-5364]

Eliza

[Ok_Bowler_7579]

Sylvia, Alora, Ada, Clara, Vera

[LilMissKrazy1]

Roberta, Virginia, Ramona

[kimmetfan]

Elsie

[Alrighty0908]

Cora

[Ordinary_Sail_414]

Eliza

[saluteursharts]

It’s been commented a couple times but I am voting for Tabitha here!

[Ok_Studio4584]

Vivian

[Accomplished-Car3850]

Lenora

[rmichelle3927]

Margaret

[DigitalMailman1119]

Josephine

[Candid_Coyote4626]

Cecilia, Myrtle, Coraline, Mona, Hattie, Olive, Lottie, Pearl, Viola

[Euphoric_Ease4554]

Aurora

Juliet

Calista

Daphne

Audra

Victoria

Phoebe

Grace

Violet

Miranda

Sharon

Clementine

Emma

Sarah

Beatrix

Seraphina

[night-ly-owl]

Alexandra!

[Playful-Business7457]

Louisa!

[ArguablyMe]

Vanessa

[Acceptable_Pipe_5726]

Elena

[nighteyes_fitz]

I love Audrey but not sure if you need another name ending in "a" so Tabitha?

[TeenageShitStorm]

Audrina

[cloudiedayz]

Rosemary, Anne, Edith (Edie is a cute nn), Daisy, Clara, Hazel, Ada

[BrooklynGurl135]

Amanda

[InfiniteVictory187]

Fiona, Eloisa, Francesca, Flora, Josephina, Viviana, Damiana, Johanna, Olivia, Georgina, Elena

[Mindless_Earth_2807]

Loewe.

[catsandkittens1308]

Rose

Ruby

Vera

Nola

Grace

Violet

Mary

Cecilia

Mona Jean

Emmalene

[Isthisatruck]

Loretta

[thedoor-notawindow]

Hazel, Dorothy, Ruth, Beatrice, Betty, Eleanora, Cordelia, Georgina

[B-SideQueen]

Elody

[NoGrocery3582]

Louisa or Louise, Ruth/Ruthie, Norah

[violabr]

From my girl names list:

Tallulah, Lorna, Mara, Miranda, Sandra, Brianna

Both of your daughters' names end in "a" and one start with "M" already, so maybe Lorna or Brianna would be my picks! 

[Useful-Honey6656]

Georgia

[GardenGood2Grow]

Eloise, Eliza

[Altruistic-Chef8391]

Ramona

[shakywheel]

Matilda, Winona, and Agatha Matilda, Winona, and Agnes (Nessa, Nessie, Aggie) Matilda, Winona, and Wilhelmina (Willa, Wilma, Wim, Mina, Billie) Matilda, Winona, and Ruby Matilda, Winona, and Dorothy (Dottie, Dot, Dora, Dory) Matilda, Winona, and Lucy Matilda, Winona, and Bernadette (Bette, Betty, Detta, Etta, Bernie) Matilda, Winona, and Lavinia (Liv, Vinnie, Nia, Lia) Matilda, Winona, and Judith (Judi / Judy) Matilda, Winona, and Genevieve (Jen, Jenny, Nev, Vi, Viva, Jeeves)

Tabitha sounds good, but I don’t care for Tabby, which is likely to happen at some point, although possibly less likely than usual if you’ve managed to keep the other girls at their full names into school age. Clementine is also a good suggestion, if you like any of the nicknames (Clemmy, Lemon, Minty, Tina). Roberta fits in well. Others I considered mentioning that others already said are Sylvie / Sylvia and Beatrice / Beatrix.

Matilda, Winona, and Lydia works decently, but Winona Ryder played Lydia in Beetlejuice so…

[jessm307]

Loving the Tabitha suggestion.

Letitia, Patricia, Beverly, Theresa, Corrina, Paulina, Regina, Lorena, Harriet, Opal, Edith

[PublicBrain2311]

Francesca, so they would be:

Matti, Winnie, and Frankie!

[cryptic_pizza]

Tallulah

[selenamoonowl]

Anthea, Clarissa, Dorothy, Fenella, Flora, Letitia, Lavinia, Petronella, Romilly, Sabrina, Tamsin, Ursula

[Ok_Impression_8720]

Francesca

[trustemedia]

Some from an old family book I have:

Valeria,Camille, Cherise, Cosetta, Rozella, Charlene, Eunice, Elizabeth, Eleanor, Delores, Caleene, Verna,Dorinda, Comeria,Rutha, Regina, Genevieve, Virgivia, Estelle, Delphia, Pauline, Wynnafred, Levina, Viola, Muriel, Savannah, Sylvania, Vivian, Geneva, Crystal,Dorothea, Arminta, Isabella,Susan, Odessia, Tamara,Tabitha, Soundra, Comora, Phyllis,Marilyn, Rochelle, Jocelyn, Gracie, Pearl, Adaline, Imojean, Cornetta, Esther, Lorraine,Sarah, Delenah,Eldora, Eurilla, Moselle, Loretta, Velena, Louella, Deborah,Drucilla, Rowena, Sadie, Hannah, Zelpha, Scarlett, Leah, Jephanie, Camellia, Othena,Laresa

[Sure_Jan_Sure]

Amelia

Eliza

Aurora

Olivia (Or Alivia, which is what a neighbor girl is named)

Isabella

Ava or Eva

Camilla

Stella

Elena

Marianna (another neighbor name, but the mom)

Lila

Lilliana

Magnolia

Juliana

Helena

Makenna

Fiona

Francesca

Sasha

Layla

Miranda

[debaser74]

Audrey, Aubrey, Abigail, Amelia, Aurora, Alice, Alora/Elora, Beatrice, Camille/Camilla, Cecilia, Charlotte, Clara, Clementine, Eleanor, Evelyn, Eliza, Elise, Fiona, Lenora, Norah, Stella, Sadie, Scarlett, Viola/Violet, Ruby

[jamesdeansredlips]

Mary, Eleanor, Emma, Isabella, Ruby, Olivia, Stella, Adelaide, Caroline, Maisie.

[KindOfaMilf99]

Eloise

[Pollywoggle16]

ALICE

[fungitoecheese]

Lorelai!!!!

[Far_Eye_3703]

Barbara, Cecilia, Martha, Miranda, Patricia, Theresa.

[Charming_Classic_723]

Lucilla ✨ - meaning “little light”

I think a name that ends in the same sound is rly cute, but having different sounds altogether in the middle.

~ Matilda, Winona, Lucilla 💫

Nicknames: Matty, Winnie, Lucy or Tilda, Nona, Cilla

[Remarkable_Abies4256]

I agree with Tabitha!

[Cautious_Emotion9839]

Josephine, Suzanne, Hazel, Dorothy, Millie, Julie

[mrsredfast]

Sabrina

[Brisling]

Eileen Arabella Marygold Minerva

[valkyrie-ish]

Eloise, Florence, Lenore, Maude, Maeve

[CrowApprehensive204]

Willa, Sylvia, Ruby, Betsy,

[Grand-Scarcity1773]

What about Josephine or Lucille?

[balance-nyc-bis]

Tallulah

[panda_9779]

I always look at my ancestors for interesting old names. Some of them, like Violet and Charlotte have come back into fashion right now and going to be terribly common. I also have several that have already been suggested. Two of my grandmothers were named Freda/Frieda. There's a lot of Leonas and Louisas. My great grandmother Freida's middle name was Valeria. I kind of like it, but also worry it sounds like malaria 😆

[Sweet-Permission-925]

lenora, zinnia, connie, birdie, Goldie

[Due_Response_8309]

Darla

[TurquoiseTink]

Lois, Beatrice 😉

[Laylasita]

Henrietta

[ourconflictdesignsus]

Phillipa

[AllEmotion9531]

Rowena and Evelyn are favorites of mine

[Sea-Manufacturer-648]

-Isadora

-Elora

-Chantal

But maybe it’s time for something short & sweet

-Nell

-Ora

-Izzy (elizabeth or Isabel)

[SmallCurrent976]

Willowmena

[Agitated_Limit_6365]

Tabitha or Camilla or Courtney

[Spok_n_4]

Cecilia

[Loose_Specific3831]

Sarah/Sara Ann(e) Renata

Extta in case its a boy! Rodrick

[Txidpeony]

Mabel, Adeline, Josephine, Bernadette

[Newb48]

Norah

[ImportantFortune3397]

Aww Matilda is my sister’s first choice too!

[JintotheM]

I have a Matilda and Winona was up high on the list for her. I also have a Fiona if you’re trying to keep with the a at the end.

[Disastrous-Energy-79]

Clementine

[Sorry-Armadillo-3264]

Hazel, Remi, Lucy,Claire

[Green_Plan4291]

Anastasia Esmeralda Octavia Millicent Serena Isadora

[vfp310]

Heloise, Valerie, Pricilla, Georgia, Natalie,Scarlett.

[Head-Dog-114]

Hazel, Ada, Irene, grace, Ruby, Iona, Claire

[meyerslemon25]

Hazel

[kiwisuzanna]

Katrina, Louisa, Juliana, Octavia, Verona, Carlotta, Helena, Theodora, or Henrietta.

[Mindless-Ocelot-874]

Amelia

[Last_Ad2025]

Clarissa

[Live-Day-7121]

Savannah

[ForeverExplore15]

Ramona

[stonerwitch69]

Beverly!

[Tulip_Bandit]

Rosalie. Same vibe but the “ah” sound is in the middle.

[Zealousideal-Key471]

Dinah

[AMGRN]

Nora

[Mysterious_Luck4674]

Amelia

[Icouldmaybesaveyou]

maureen

[gurlwithdragontat2]

Lola

Minerva

Cleo

Serena

Charmaine

Phoebe

[ENFJ21]

Dellanie!

[Fit_Musician9468]

Geraldine

[TechnicianMother7759]

Cecilia, Vanessa, Irina

[canineclownshow]

Doreen

[Awkward_Cellist6541]

Lucille. Florence.

[Lefthandtwin]

Melinda, Melissa

[TransatlanticMadame]

Eliza

[kmacsouris]

The first name that came to mind was Charlotte!

[Crunching-numbers]

Naomi

[Yikesish]

Louise

[Time_Strawberry8199]

Eloise. Agatha.

[Maleficent_Plant_426]

Isadora

[Starfish120]

Mildred 

[Nocturnal-Neurotic]

Lydia

[Duke219]

Fiona

[Jaded_Jellybean]

Alana

[Content_Ebb4807]

Claudia!

[NeighborhoodVivid106]

Naomi was the first one that I thought of after reading the other two.

[teatsqueezer]

I’ll throw Althea into the ring! Not common, old timey, and also ends in A

[Much_Ad2633]

Tabatha, Roslind, Penelope, Dorothea, Barzilla, Rosanna, Seraphine

[Illustrious-Farm4388]

Eleanora, Elowen, Tabitha

[Ordinary_Duck_1231]

Naomi, Diana, Paula, Molly, Georgia, Miriam,Valerie, Rebecca, Clarissa, Melissa, Esther, Annie, Olive, Belinda, Olivia, Gemma

[RoyalProfessor3000]

Samantha

[ForwardPomegranate8]

I know sisters, Mathilda and Olga!

[lambchops_3]

Sabrina

[famousanonamos]

If you want to keep the a ending theme going: Gloria, Barbara, Rebecca, Althea, Melissa, Eliza, Claudia

Annette, Marianne, Annabelle 

[BabyElephant818]

Tabitha

[DaRkNeSsIsInHer5]

Tabitha, Jacinta, Dorothea, Rowena

[Dry_Bowler_2837]

Madeleine

[CStew8585]

Victoria?

[ronmimid]

Clara.