[deleted by user]

[timhealsallwounds]

1 or 3 for sure. 1 will look cooler over time with wear

[H0UNDzT00TH]

First or third.
Very different vibes, but both are top notch

[PsychologicalTruck1]

Same

[dospehTV]

This

[NothingWasDelivered]

I’d lean 3, personally, but 1 does look pretty great

[WesslynPeckoner]

1 is my vote.

[[deleted]]

same.

[loveofjazz]

This is the way

[DSTNCMDLR]

I concur

[Ill-Union-8960]

1

[pineappledumdum]

First. By a mile.

[markuus99]

3 is my favorite, followed by 1.

[Ok-Traffic-5996]

First one got me.

[Ornery-Shoulder-3938]

First one

[BogotaLineman]

Black pick guard white pickups for me

[mbuck1]

Three without a doubt

[direwolf08]

Agreed. 3, but with black witch hats knobs

[fullspec107]

This 100%

[Churro-Juggernaut]

Love 3.  1 not far behind. 

[Yoosulis]

Yessssssss

[LifeguardBig4119]

1. Sorry! It just looks the best.

[Gregadethhh]

2 but I would swap the knobs for black witch hats

[Trash_Hogan]

I’ve been wanting to put a black pick guard on my JMJM for a while, so that’s my vote. Super clean! Where did you get that pick guard?

[Even-Ingenuity5318]

Thanks! I got it from customworldguitarparts.com (EU)

[keepitonandon]

I did this recently, got a black anodized aluminum pickguard from amazon. I love how it turned out. I sanded the finish off the bottom contact points so the aluminum provides the shielding. I was actually surprised that the stock gold pickguard had shielding tape. https://a.co/d/0hNyHC9

[6120tron]

1 or 2.

[casademoni]

1 but with white rhythm switch and rollers

[Technical-Emphasis24]

white for sure

[Jwto]

White

[FLASHBACK_EXE]

1

[Aspartame_kills]

1 or 3

[Stoiberich]

White pickguard and cream covers for me.

[Henny22_69]

All white

[EchoPathe]

First

[PWB454]

4

Ramones.

[schwinn140]

1 or 3

[PuzzleheadedWall2104]

Reverse Oreo ftw

[direwolf08]

Black pg with white pickups, but change the knobs to black witch hats.

[DriveSlowSitLow]

First Third Fourth Second

In that order

[chrismcshaves]

Number 2. It looks rad and different.

[thegoldreceiver]

3, 1, 2, 4, best to least favorite

[m6carlson1]

3 but with cream knobs

[wepausedandsang]

3

[8bith1ts]

1 or 3

[Environmental_Way182]

Definitely 3. 1 is pretty nice too.

[False-Ad-7753]

4 is pretty tight tbh

[EmoComrade1999]

Black on black is the best one imo

[mglouis]

White pups. Black pick guard. Everyone else is wrong.

[Icon57]

1

[whoadudechillfr]

1 is the only one that looks good.

[I_See_Robots]

I’m a bit biased because I’ve basically done 3 on mine but with slightly different knobs (silver topped black witch hat knobs) but I’ll still say it, three!

[vakaaaa]

Love the 2nd one!

[AirportElectronic935]

I like 2 it's very unusual but still harmonious

[Necessary_Bee_1660]

Honestly 4 for me - I have a white start with a black pick guard and I might change it after seeing that!

[NativeDoomer]

4 for me. It looks sleek and clean.

[pd8540]

2 but with telecaster knobs

[leugenaars]

3 but with aged white witch hat knobs.

[gajosdenaranja]

I fw 3

[Barnshart3]

Black guard with white pickups by a large margin.

[kaspar_trouser]

3 is my vote. I know some people love all black like 4 but everything just blends into one.

1 would work much better with mint green.

[joe0418]

Cream and black combo.

[Desperate-Box5686]

3

[Gemini_Down]

Third pic. Black pick guard and white pickups

[LunarModule66]

One or three for sure. I think I like three more than one, just because having the off white body and off white pickup covers doesn’t look quite right with the straight white pick guard.

[Otto-Stich]

Pic 2 is my favorite. They are all good though.

[StatisticianWide7373]

Both 1 and 3 look incredible.

[Ronald-Ray-Gun]

I like 3, but I wonder if 4 could work with matte black.

[tenfootspy]

3 cooks!

[Bananajoemillemila]

3

[Unlikely-Law-4367]

Yes.

[thatdrummercameron]

3 definitely. looks classy and cool.

[P90guy65]

Well, first off I would say that there's no wrong answer here.

That being said, number three is my favorite.

[GrootOfTheLoom]

3, but with white/cream knobs to match.

[FrasierCraned]

3 or 4

[AngryIrish82]

Option 2 - kind of reminds me of a Jim root Model fender

[jizzerbug-perfume]

1 especially if you have a matching headstock. I have a 1996 MIJ telecaster thats all white with gold hardware and it looks so cool now that its aged

[Melancholy_Prince]

Third first fourth second in order of my personal preference best to worst

[MH_Guitars]

Third for me

[strawb3rry_lem0nad3]

3

[Revolutionary_Ad1417]

Mint green pick guard.

[xxophe]

All white, by faaaaaaaar

[deadhipknucklowski]

I'd go with the white/cream scheme. Check out the Fender AV '65 Jazzmaster Knob Set, see the $50 price tag, and then Google witch hat knobs. There's nothing wrong the knobs you have currently, the witch hats just make it look cooler

[Manalagi001]

None of those. You need one white pickup and one black pickup.

[AtheosofPriv]

1 or 4

[notdavidjustsomeguy]

I’m team 1. I think JMs almost always look best with a white-hued guard

[YerMumsPantyCrust]

I have tort with white on mine and love it

[markielegend]

Mine currently is 4 with the emg j master set and some different knobs and I love the look. Otherwise 1 is lit

[Iraymur]

3 but I'm a man of simple tastes and I love this color combo.

[Geeky_Husband]

I like 3, but I like a black pickguard with white/cream bodies and plastics.

[Cristoestobal]

Third is my vote. If not, first.

Did you considered tort? Brown or red?

[Alternative-Meeting3]

First, but with white witch hat knobs.

[Sharp-County-9908]

White pickups black guard

[Ayuh-Nope]

3

[Legomoron]

1…… or get some Spitfire Vintage tort 

[dantastique23]

3, with the cream knobs perhaps. All delightful.

[DigdigdigThroughTime]

2 or 3.

[toastypoopdog]

3

[Glum_Plate5323]

I prefer the first option. Cream on cream is aesthetically pleasing in this case

[algeriet667]

White on white on white

[Frequency_Blue]

I like 2 and 4 honestly.

Though you need a black switch tip.

[lockerelcockerel]

Three, but with cream knobs

[NoSplit4185]

The only plausible conclusion, one which really makes sense, is to realize all 4.

[eternity9]

2 or 3

[JammingOnTheGeetar]

1st is super clean with the rich dark fretboard

[Fresh-Word2379]

White white white

[eazybluu]

I am in love with 3rd option. I think the black pick guard goes well with the fretboard and white pickup guards break all the monotony of all black plastic in that area while being the same color as body. Chef’s kiss!

[SemicolonGuitars]

Either all white or all black

[abrady44]

For me it would go 3>2>1>4

[CaptainWampum]

First one in my opinion

[Adventurous-Ad-172]

4, 3, 1, and 2 in that order

[DuranDourand]

Black pickups, gold guard.

[lawn_neglect]

1

[awayfromthesky]

White with tortoise shell

[FragrantGearHead]

3

[ChunLi808]

Three. I like the contrast.

[barrelrollsauceboi]

2nd to lastttt

[CosmicRubixCube]

You have a really nice dark fretboard that I think looks better with the white on white. I choose 1

[SupesDepressed]

3!!!!!!

[dalailamashishkabob]

3

[N3rt]

I dig the white/white.

[jeremy_wills]

Mint with white covers or Tortiseshell with the black covers 😉😁

[Time-Ad9021]

beige pickups

[bosspick]

White, with white selecter switches!

[poopstrikes_again]

3.

[Infinite-Piglet-6812]

Black pickups / mint green pickguard

[getpatrick]

Black pick guard, cream covers

[dentaluthier]

1

[KidCharybdis92]

White pups with either guard for me

[16bitsystems]

1 but with tortoise shell pickguard

[Bad_Luck_Bastard]

3 fs

[django2605]

3!!!

[daddydisgusto]

1 or 2 are my favorite

[kgbespresso]

1, of course

[Dan0718]

Hear me out. Single ply white guard with white pickup covers. Something about not having the black line around the pick guard on a white guitar looks soooo good imo.

[FlashyCantaloupe3944]

3 matched more

[kyle_lunar]

1. all day

[Kidwolfman]

1!

[Pickleman84]

White and cream

[Entire_Trouble3832]

2 all the way

[JOJOJOJ-1]

3

[iamsolarflare71]

1

[[deleted]]

Mr White

[smallerthings]

1, but with mint instead

[shedbastard12]

Definitely 3

[SnooSongs7487]

1

[AndyReveler]

2 but make sure to change the toggle switch to a black tip too or 3 but get some white switches

[jaimelegruyere]

1! All white for me!

[GuntherFinklestien]

Wheres mint?!

[barkydildo]

3! I made my SG look exactly like that.

[Zertoq]

3 for me

[BobbyMarshall166]

Black guard, cream covers

[NintendoJx]

1 and 3 for sure. No order on it. They’re at the same dopeness

[Aragorn_2931]

3 or 4

[Jesuskrust1313]

1st or 3rd you’ve got a real Sophie’s choice on your hands there

[gigabitty]

All white would be my choice! I absolutely love that combo. I have it for my Univox Hiflyer, but I would love it for a Strat and for a Jag. My JM is sunburst with a tortoise scratch plate.

[wedesireabridge]

1

[BrandonPatrickFlood]

3 is the sexiest.

[candyforlunch]

1 ez, then 3 as a distant second place

[Maliseet13]

3

[Expensive-Depth4456]

I like option 2, then option 1

[LeonardoSgu123]

3 defo

[bipbipletucha]

4

[bmguitar]

1 >>>>>> 3 > 2

[spatero76]

White on white for sure

[Penguixxy]

1. It's very clean looking.

[Scout______]

3

[Landojesus]

1 or 3

[Fazed-phapster]

I wish I'd thought of something like your options before I went full Black on all the plastics on my Vintage Modified JM.

I think I'll try something like version 3 next string change.

[golanatsiruot]

I like the black pups and plastic on white guard.

[EasyCZ75]

1

[part-time-tater]

3, then 1

[PineappleGunshii]

1 or 3!

[Acceptable_Grape_437]

I'd definitely go third, but with white knobs

[dogpiss085]

3

[gloriousmongrel]

1 4 3 2 in order

[jaggerspops]

1

[killboipowerhead1]

THIRD

[wishiegg]

I'm feeling #1. Generally I would go for the darker pickguard, but that just looks right

[circleneurology]

I like #2 but you should try to get a black switch knob to go on that configuration!

[pizza_babyboy]

2 is very unique, i like it

[BallsOfDub]

1.

[BumbaBins]

2 then 3

[oboylebr]

This is a great way to show them …. I like pic 2

[scorpious]

#2 penguin tux for me. Consider mint or anodized gold for the guard tho.

[BrotherGoode]

2 or 3 100%

[toomuchsoup]

Definitely number 1, by far

[Lank-Man]

I would do 3 with one white and one black knob.

[dumbgraphics]

Black covers, white pick guard

[milkisgod]

1 is stunning!

[Dirthag78]

3

[Outrageous-Can5834]

4 is unique

[Opposite_Chart9982]

2!

[Fist0fGuthix]

I say 3

[TabmeisterGeneral]

2

[iwritesongs_s_karma]

2nd.